Journal of Comparative Psychology italicizeditalicized2.
Processing pitch in a nonhuman mammal Chinchilla laniger. The paper may have made an incorrect or imperfect assumption. Due to the subjective nature of this judgment, it is all the more important that your writing is clearand well-matched to what a reviewer is looking for i.
Finally, the cover letter provides a location for you to write any "off-the-record" comments regarding the paper.
Then, start presenting specific comments on the paper. Further reading Pannell, D. Regardless, there are some invariant questions that most reviewers would or at least should always consider, including: Alamy 1 Have a strategy, make a plan Why do you want to write for journals.
Unfortunately, some treat a graph as a piece of art and refuse to acknowledge that most graphs will be computer generated. He should write several separate parts. You will need to evaluate whether the author has clearly interpreted the results of the study, or whether the results could be interpreted another way.
The reviewer should avoid language that can be easily misconstrued or that appears condescending, including obscure or loaded vocabulary as well as humour, irony, and sarcasm. There are a wide variety of review styles from ones aimed at a general audience e.
Your paper should consist of four general sections: The paper is immediately suspect but not necessarily wrong or obsolete if all of the references are old. You, an expert in the subject, should be able to find it if it exists. Research what people are currently discussing in the society.
Write a powerful introduction paragraph. Here is a format to use in such cases. The following text offers some tips to the referee to assist in the preparation of a written review. A reference list containing papers only by the author deserves special, and skeptical, scrutiny.
To what extent does the paper solve the problem it describes. When writing your review, consider the type of review that you would like to receive. Most feedback will help you improve your paper and, perhaps, your journal article writing, but sometimes it may seem overheated, personalised or even vindictive.
It is characterized by single actions per sentence and lots of unnecessary details. It is important to focus on writing an outline. How to write a journal article review example. Reject unconditionally, because the likelihood of successful revision is remote.
Start by saying something positive about the paper, no matter how difficult this is.
The first sentence usually gives the rationale for the research, and the last asserts a 'contribution to knowledge'. For example, a paper might be a complete piece of work, but it might also be a survey, a tutorial, or simply a proposal.
The ideal review will be fair, unbiased, speedy, and confidential. If bits need rewriting, say so in your review. Received March 27, Abstract Peer review of journal articles and other technical reports is a key element in the maintenance of academic integrity.
The article name comes next, followed by the title of the journal in italicsvolume number in italics and issue number in parentheses. However, in your article evaluation, you should mention the weak sides of the content.
Here the author assumes the reader has basic knowledge of microbiological techniques and has deleted other superfluous information. Sometimes the recommendations fit better in the cover letter. Make this short summary the beginning of your review, as well.
In most cases, new uncorrectable problems or new major concerns raised in later reviews should only apply to changes in a paper that have emerged through the authors' revision work. Strive for an impersonal, non-critical, and informative account. How to Write an Article Review How to Write an Article Review.
Sep 07, An article review is a type of professional paper writing. It demands a high level of in-depth analysis and a well-structured presentation of arguments.
A research article review differs from a journal article review by the way that it evaluates the research. Nov 16, · Start your review by referring to the title and author of the article, the title of the journal, and the year of publication in the first paragraph.
For example: The article, "Condom use will increase the spread of AIDS," was written by Anthony Zimmerman, a Catholic priest%(). Sometimes, journal editors will invite scientists to write a review for their journal. Choosing a Topic If you need to write a review article but don't know where to start, keep some of these tips in mind.
and well-referenced review for a journal article. If existing commitments will prevent write the first two paragraphs of your review, which will sum- warrants publication in their journal.
Does the paper present a case study of a known phenomenon in a new system (an incre. How to Write a Good Paper for a Top International Journal Elsevier Author Workshop Hohai University, October 22, Writing a scientific paper is an intense intellectual activity.
The writing process ¾To present a review of the field or to summarize a. Mar 06, · Before asking ‘how,’ the question of ‘why’ is more important when starting to write a review. The main and fundamental purpose of writing a review is to create a readable synthesis of the best resources available in the literature for an important research question or a current area of research.How to write a review journal paper